Posted by: Kathy Temean | January 29, 2010

Children Reading Preferences

Since we write for children, I figured you would be interested in the post that David L Harrison brought up on his blog.  I thought the information was very interesting and felt you would, too.

This issue of Language Arts (January 2010) includes an article by Denise Davila and Lisa Patrick. The article is called “Asking the Experts: What Children Have to Say about Their Reading Preferences” and presents the findings of several studies on the subject. The authors remind us, “For the most part, adults control the world of children’s literature: adults write the books; adults choose which books to publish; adults review the books; adults bestow the awards on books; and adults purchase the books for their homes, book stores, and libraries. In the midst of all this adult control, children’s opinions are often overlooked.”

In one of the reported studies, the authors observe, “. . . when reading options are limited, students are left with three choices: reading something outside of their interests, obtaining their preferred materials themselves, or not reading at all. Students who cannot afford to buy their preferred materials are more dependent on school sources and, thus, their choices are even more limited.”

Several studies in the article present their findings when groups of boys and girls were asked what they like to read. Generally, both genders in grades three to five like scary, funny, and action-packed stories.

In general, avid readers of both sexes share many of the same reading interests although there are some differences. Girls more frequently choose fiction and boys more frequently choose nonfiction. Girls more frequently prefer to read catalogues, song lyrics, poetry, and cookbooks. Boys more frequently read informational materials about videogames, sports, cars, and trucks. Boys also like fantasy, crime/detective stories, and war/spy stories, comics, graphic novels, and joke books.

Where does poetry come in? Among 3,865 girls in one study, poetry was liked by 42%. Magazines (82%) ranked number one followed by text messaging, television, websites, catalogues, song lrics, jokes, fiction, newspapers, and comics. In a study of 4,341 boys, poetry came in at 22%. The only thing that ranked lower were plays, travel books, and cookbooks. Boys’ favorites were magazines, websites, jokes, comics, text messages, television, fiction, and newspapers.

I think this article gives us several points to consider, beginning with how hard it is to get past all the adults to reach our young audiences. We need to be aware that children do have rather specific tastes in what they prefer to read and among the few places where they have much control over their selections is on the Internet, when reading articles and stories in magazines, and text messaging with friends. Many children love books, too, but may have a hard time getting to the kinds of books they like.

This article concludes, “Just as children currently have strong preferences for reading subject matter that they access on websites or interactively construct via text messaging, it is inevitable that children’s reading preferences will continue to shift with the evolution of new media and technologies.”


Responses

  1. I’ve thought a bit about this since reading David’s original post. Most children don’t really get to pick what they read. It is the teachers and parents, or just the parents for the early years. Even in later years, the kids that don’t like to read (like my boys 😦 ) read only what is required by their teachers. So are we ultimately writing for the adults or for the few kids who really like reading? (That was me, 10 books at a time from the library.) With more and more children reading online, can we write more for the kids and less for their adult censors?

    Like

  2. Yousei,

    I doubt it, but it’s a nice thought.

    Kathy

    Like

  3. Hi Kathy

    I am really interested In reading the article that you have referenced above.

    I am a teaching student currently in my final year of studying primary education. This year we are required to submit a personal research project and I am very interested in the area of children’s reading choices and attitudes to reading.

    Would it be possible for you to send me a copy of this article?

    Any help would be much appreciated

    Kind regards
    Dawn

    Like

    • Dawn,

      I don’t have the article. Perhaps David L Harrison has it and could help.

      Kathy

      Like

  4. Kathy,

    Thank you I will ask him.

    Dawn

    Like


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Categories

%d bloggers like this: